• Directory of Taiwan

Germany found to have raised white flag for Taiwan

Germany deletes Taiwan flag from foreign ministry website for 'one China policy'

Blank space under the Taiwan flag. (Federal Foreign Office screenshot)

Blank space under the Taiwan flag. (Federal Foreign Office screenshot)

TAIPEI (Taiwan News) — Germany was found to have unceremoniously replaced Taiwan's flag with a blank, white banner under its listing for the country on the foreign ministry website — prompting one reporter to ask if it was a white flag of surrender to China.

The Federal Foreign Office website recently deleted the flag of Taiwan and replaced it with a plain, white rectangle. During a press conference on Friday (July 10) the foreign ministry representative claimed the change was in keeping with Germany's "one China policy."

At the 1:01:12 mark of an hour-long press conference on Friday, a German reporter asked, "Why did Taiwan's flag disappear and become a blank column in the introduction of national conditions of various countries on the official website of the German foreign ministry? Is this a white flag raised to the Chinese? What's going on? Except for Taiwan, other countries have flags. What is going on with the German foreign ministry?"

In response, the foreign ministry's deputy spokesman, Rainer Breul, said that "it isn't a current change."

Unsatisfied with the response, the reporter pressed further by asking "whether currently or not, is it missing? Why did you remove it?" Breul responded by saying, "You know Taiwan's special status, you know our position, our 'one China policy,' we have no diplomatic relations with Taiwan, and Taiwan is not a country we recognize, so this is not surprising. When we introduce regions of the world, we distinguish them from countries with diplomatic ties."

Refusing to take the canned response, the reporter replied, "Since when did the official website of the German Foreign Ministry no longer use Taiwan's flag?" He then asked why the Palestinian flag can still be found on the website even though it is not an officially recognized country.

Breul replied by saying he would give reporters more information later. The press conference was then brought to an end.

Twitter user "Chiang Kai Shek" pointed out the flag of Palestine does indeed appear, while for Taiwan the website displays the white flag, the international symbol for surrender. He then asks, "Germany thinks Taiwan surrendered?"

Update 07/13 6:15 p.m.

In response to the removal of Taiwan's flag from the website, Taiwan Ministry of Foreign Affairs Spokesperson Joanne Ou (歐江安) on Monday stated that the ministry is unable to accept such a discrepancy because the page introducing Taiwan is inconsistent with other countries or regions. She said that as a consequence, this "will only cause unnecessary misunderstandings with the people of all countries."

She added that MOFA has instructed its representative office in Germany to communicate with the German Federal Foreign Office and solemnly explain Taiwan's position. She then stated that "We express our hope that the German side can properly adjust the web design of the German Federal Foreign Office in a more equitable and consistent manner to avoid discriminatory misunderstandings."

Update 07/13 7:52 p.m.

An earlier version of this article described the appearance of the white flag on the foreign ministry site as "sudden." It now appears the flag has been on the site for some time; however, its discovery by Taiwanese media and MOFA can be characterized as "sudden."

Germany found to have raised white flag for Taiwan
Taiwan: Characteristics. (Federal Foreign Office screenshot)